ReadKiddoRead.com Logo

PRINT THIS PAGE

The Case of the Cat with the Missing Ear (The Adventures of Samuel Blackthorne series)
By Scott Emerson
The Case of the Cat with the Missing Ear (The Adventures of Samuel Blackthorne series)
Simon & Schuster, 2003
Pages: 240
Suggested Ages: 9 and Up
ISBN-13: 9780689858611

Meet Yorkshire terrier detective Samuel Blackthorne as seen through the eyes of his chronicler, friend, and fellow canine, Edward R. Smithfield, a retired veterinarian. In their first thrilling case together, they come to the assistance of elegant greyhound, Molly Kirkpatrick, who seeks their help to find out why her brother, Patrick, a shy, hardworking accountant, failed to return from a neighborhood pub the night before.

Written in the style of Sherlock Holmes' Dr. Watson, Smithfield's meticulous narrative describes Blackthorne's "uncanny ability to see things other dogs couldn't and to smell things other dogs wouldn't" as he prowls the foggy streets of San Francisco in 1887 and contends with kidnapping, gambling, nefarious politicians, and even murder. Blackthorne's special talent is in employing the powers of observation and deduction.

When readers then migrate to the source of Scott Emerson's dog-based homage, the Sherlock Holmes stories by Arthur Conan Doyle, they will recognize and appreciate the ornate Victorian style of the narrative and revel in the diabolically clever deductive reasoning skills of the great detective. The videos and movies about Sherlock Holmes starring Basil Rathbone or Jeremy Brett make for some fine watching and a stirring introduction to the series.

Teachers, here's an activity to help readers sharpen their own deductive reasoning skills. After reading aloud the first chapter, where Blackthorne explains how he has drawn so many accurate conclusions about his new friend, Smithfield, ask your students to pair off and see what they can deduce about each other. For a descriptive writing activity, writers can secretly observe another child or a teacher and write a detailed description of that person, both physical, and deductive. When they read these aloud, others can try to identify the person.

THEMES: CALIFORNIA. CATS. DOGS. MYSTERY AND DETECTIVE STORIES. SAN FRANCISCO (CALIFORNIA). WRITING.